Everything Old is New Again: From "No Nukes" to "Nukes Now" with Dr. Patrick Moore

| | Comments (3762) | TrackBacks (5)
Here at CV we spend most of our time looking at new technologies, the future, and how a rush to judgment or a poor public relations decision can doom a promising technology, service, or company to failure. We see how sensationalism, poor reporting and massive "click to complain" campaigns can generate outrage where there should be none, and amplify the shrill cries of a few to the point where they dominate the public discourse.

Now, instead of looking forward, we look back to the 1960's, when the relatively new technology of nuclear power brought a promise of unlimited, clean energy. Those days also were the height of the cold war, when the fear of atomic weapons clouded the nation's judgment of atomic power. This interview, and the resulting article, should serve as a cautionary tale for those who would rush to judge a new technology out of fear rather than optimism, and for those who create, who compete against each other without thinking of what he and his competitors have in common, and how they can fight to protect each other, in order to compete.

For every nuclear plant that environmentalists avoided, they ended up causing two coal plants to be built. That's the history of the last 20 years. Most new power plants in this country are coal, because the environmentalists opposed nuclear. When you ask someone like the NRDC, 'Do you prefer nuclear or coal?' They'll say 'We prefer nuclear to coal, but we don't want either.' It doesn't work that way; we need power.

--Vinod Khosla, Co-Founder, Sun Microsystems, January 2008


Vinod Khosla isn't known around Silicon Valley as a man who has bad ideas. With a net worth of around $1.5 Billion, he also knows a thing or two about a good investment.  

Dr. Patrick Moore is no slouch in getting things done either. In 1974, he founded Greenpeace, possibly the best known and most successful environmental protection group in the history of the world. 

Greenpeace, for those of you who have never heard of the Environmental movement, has been on the cutting edge of conservation for more than thirty years. It has critics who say that during those years it has either gone too far or not far enough. It has had a ship blown up by the French government. It has had one run aground on the very reef it was trying to protect. 

Ironically, what this high-tech trailblazer and environmental pioneer have in common is the embrace of something very old that is in the midst of a  renaissance: nuclear power.

Dr. Moore was on the first Greenpeace voyage in 1971 and stayed with the organization until 1986, coincidentally the same year that Khosla left Sun. Since then, he has spent his time as a consultant on environmental issues. Dr. Moore has never given up his conservationist leanings. However, whereas he first entered the public eye as an opponent of nuclear testing, nuclear weapons, and nuclear power while traveling on the Phyllis Comack to try and stop a U.S. nuclear test, today he sails a much different path. Dr. Moore wants to steer the U.S. back to being a nuclear nation in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. 

In fact, Dr. Moore is now at odds with the juggernaut he helped create. In 2007, Voz Hernandez of Greenpeace South Asia called claims that nuclear energy is a solution to climate change "dangerous and misleading." Hernandez went on to fan the flames, saying:

"Besides the massive financial costs involved in building a nuclear power plant, the risks of accidents like Chernobyl or the most recent one at Kashiwazaki nuclear plant in Japan following an earthquake are real..."

DSC_0138.JPG
 

I wouldn't have pictured this man as a founder of Greenpeace. Far from the "crunchy granola" stereotype of an environmental activist, or even the sharply dressed canvassers that I sometimes encounter outside the Metrorail escalator, I walked into a Dupont Circle cafe to meet a unassuming man dressed in a sharp grey suit, who could have been any lawyer working in the many law firms or agencies that line Washington's streets. Instead, he serves as the co-chair of the Clean and Safe Energy Coalition, and, in some way, is attempting to make up for the unintended consequences of the actions of his younger self.

Perhaps the greatest strength of the 61-year-old native of British Columbia is that he could blend into any crowd on Capitol Hill, only drawing the sword of his considerable credentials when needed. Whereas Greenpeace is now known for its loud, emotional, disruptive and often self-defeating "mind bombs," Moore is soft-spoken, thoughtful and precise. He rebuts emotional arguments like Hernandez's with a razor-sharp grasp of the facts surrounding the issue that have dominated over half his life. In fact, the first question he answered dealt with the success of nuclear power in Europe and rebutted the concerns over Chernobyl. 


"...the legacy of the nuclear waste remains unsolved and accidents continue to happen across the nuclear plants in operation around the world almost everyday."
 --Voz Hernandez

Dr. Moore projects an air of total confidence in his subject. I would love to see him in a head-to-head debate with Mr. Hernandez, as I listened to him describe how nuclear "waste" is actually fuel that we couldn't use because of law, not science. This isn't a new technology either, we've been able to do it since the cold war.



As the conversation turned to rolling out new technologies, I couldn't help but think of the Politics Online conference last week. Specifically, the debate over the rollout of broadband in the U.S., and who should take the lead. Dr. Moore agreed that broadband and nuclear power are remarkably similar in that they are essential to our national security, and suggests...*gasp* help from the government in setting national priorities.
 

What struck me as the most important part about Dr. Moore and his new crusade is how circumspect he is about his past and the role he played in creating the considerable uphill battle that nuclear energy now faces. 

Today's new technologies often face the same backlash, fears, sensationalism and poor public relations that nuclear power faced in the 1970's. The solution is to get out in front of problems and focus on the good. Of course, Silicon Valley is a dog-eat-dog world, and companies that compete with each other are loath to join together, even for a common goal, especially when government is concerned. Dr. Moore added that in any industry association that the members are, on on level or another, competing with one another.  Despite this competition, the members of said association are trying to compete in the same arena and need to band together over common goals and needs so that they can be allowed to compete with each other instead of excessive government legislation and public backlash.

A more "Capitol Valley" example of this would be the hoopla that surrounded MySpace as it gained popularity and was bought by News Corporation.  Although it has a lot of harmless and even useful applications (friends can use it to keep in touch and bands can preview their latest single) their founders and owners allowed, through lack of good PR and failure to pool resources with like-minded companies, the sensationalism and bad press to dominate its media attention and the public discourse. NBC spent entire episodes of "Dateline NBC" dedicating itself to showcasing the "predators" on the site. Bad press has forced News Corporation to entire separate agreements with almost every state Attorney General in the U.S. Some state legislatures have considered bills specifically to address social networking sites, which if written poorly or read incorrectly, could have chilling effects on any service which allows for user generated content. 

Of course, this is not out of malice, but from the best intentions. Old Media has done much to sully the reputation of New Media by dismissing it as a haven for predators, or a dangerous zone where bad things lurk behind a single click of a mouse. Yet, for every Megan Meier ( a 14-year-old girl who hung herself after being the victim of a MySpace hoax) there are literally millions of people and groups, from teens to adults, using MySpace, Facebook, and the entire range of social networking systems out there without a single negative consequence. Happily. Safely. Productively.

No one is trying to downplay the tragedy of what happened to Megan, but the fact is, what happened to her is not indicative of the overall MySpace experience.  The same thing happened with nuclear energy. Many are still focused on Chernobyl and Three Mile Island but ignore the fact that Sweden has eliminated fossil fuels from its generation of electricity, which is 50% nuclear energy and 50% hydroelectric.  France?  80% nuclear.  Deaths? Zero.

It doesn't seem like they're related, but Silicon Valley could learn a little from the missteps of U.S. Nuclear.  Band together and get the positive into the public eye.

Dr. Moore is both a very smart man and one who is brave enough to admit to a mistake and take the action to try and correct it.  His message to startups?  Don't wait until you have the worst public image in the world.  Band together, inform the public and improve your ability to grow and thrive.


Sphere: Related Content

5 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Everything Old is New Again: From "No Nukes" to "Nukes Now" with Dr. Patrick Moore.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.capitolvalley.net/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/396

This is exactly the kind of thing that I like to point out any time someone says that Web 2.0 technologies aren't good for anything more than fun.  Tom Hadfield, who at 17 sold soccer.net to ESPN for a cool... Read More

Insurance for Women. Health, Accident, California Call, log-on for quotes from Insurance for Women. Health, Accident, California Call, log-on for quotes on January 13, 2009 6:50 PM

Thinking about getting pregnant .. get insured before!!! Read More

Jewelry Combo Case from Jewelry Combo Case on August 5, 2009 9:15 AM

Jewelry Combo Case- brought to you by ABC Target. Pro Read More

cheap london hotels from cheap london hotels on September 20, 2009 11:58 AM

As you can tell by his accent, Boris is a toff , with aristocratic forbears on both sides of the family. Educated at Eton and Oxford, he is a journalist and Tory politician and recently resigned his seat in Parliament to run for London’ s Mayor, beatin... Read More

Mfa Photography Digital Imaging from Mfa Photography Digital Imaging on September 28, 2009 7:21 PM

full-time Core Program, required of all MFA students, consists of studio courses i Read More

3762 Comments

AMEN. Read the book "The Nuclear Imperative - A Critical Look at the Impending Energy Crisis", Publ. by Springer (2007); ISBN 1-4020-4930-7.

Andrew and Alex:

Great interview and interesting post.

Here is a thought exercise for you - do you really think that the Old Media portrayals of New Media as a dangerous place are accidentally inaccurate or do you think there might be an element of spreading FUD (Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt) about a rapidly growing competitor? After all, people who are interacting on social media sites and creating their own content no longer have much time to be passive consumers of old line television, magazines and newspapers.

Now, really put on your critical thinking tin foil hats. If you are a powerful and rich supplier of fossil fuels and you have worked long and hard to encourage a serious habit of consuming massive quantities of those fuels - what would you do if a bunch of physicists came along with a magic material that is 2-4 MILLION times as concentrated, is relatively cheap and easy to use, and produces so little pollution that it can be safely used inside a submarine?

Why of course - you set out to independently spread as much FUD as you can think of and you make donations (sometimes through foundations, sometimes through influencing grant decisions of the buddies you helped get elected to office) to any group that actively opposes your fast growing competitor. You cannot afford to let the atomic energy business capture your addicts!

Even if you do not totally defeat the enemy, slowing him down for a couple of decades can give you many years of immense prosperity as the demand for energy continues to increase and the atomic alternative is avoided.

Not that such a thing could ever happen in a nation of free thinking citizens!

Rod Adams
Atomic Insights

I find it ironic and extremely sad that the environmental movement is cutting all of our throats by being vehemently anti-nuclear. The math is simple: opposition to nuclear power ONLY means that every time baseline power increases, then CO2 emissions increase!

Personally, I think that Greenpeace should be forced to pay a carbon emission tax just for the luxury of being anti-nuclear, and an additional tax for being anti-nuclear because of false conclusions propagated by their institution. Democracy is wonderful, and they have the right to act as they want, but when their actions cause more CO2 emissions, they are every bit as morally culpable as EVERY manufacturing industry in this country.

So, if Greenpeace want to continue to be a major contributor to the melting Arctic Circle and the increased threat of a global flooding catastrophe, then tax them for their past contributions to this problem, and continue taxing them now and until they start acting responsibly about the truth of nuclear energy!

Best Regards,

Dr. Cris Eberle
Critical Solutions Engineering, LLC
criticalsolutions@charter.net

Dr. Eberle,

I think Dr. Moore is rather honest and contrite regarding his role in the anti-nuclear movement of the 1960s and 1970s.

Something I didn't press him on, because honestly I didn't feel it was germane to the interview topic, was if he felt any personal debts for any problems the movement has caused, or if he feels a need to "pay penance" for derailing the Nuke train "back in the day."

That being said, I think he has done a wonderful job of bringing together a diverse group of opposing interests under the banner of bringing nuclear energy back into the public eye in a positive way, and that Dr. Moore, with his unique and checkered past, is in fact acting quite responsibly. Please note that he is no longer associated with Greenpeace, and that Greenpeace considers him to be an apostate to their cause. Dr. Moore no more speaks for Greenpeace than I do the Linux User Group I founded at my high school 10 years ago.

Time passes, and people change. Maybe if you'd listened to the interview, you'd realize that.

Tell me please, where you can buy a children's bicycle in the internet?
It is a very urgent need! For example of such internet shop: shop
Thanks in advance!

[url=http://www.divinecaroline.com/public/user/profile?user_id=83997]earning money 101waystoincome.com[/url]

[url=http://www.divinecaroline.com/public/user/profile?user_id=83997]earning money 101waystoincome.com[/url]

drxsc slwvutn sctvroi jkhufp quslvy gqadhk pygdmxcjz

drxsc slwvutn sctvroi jkhufp quslvy gqadhk pygdmxcjz

xzpu enqdri oyhqb ilaxp xngslhqzk rsic xqpbyvc http://www.gksv.eoluxgk.com

omwart lgfrcn ocik
http://themall.freemysqlphphosting.com/com2570.html baby fluff juicy couture samarium cobalt magnets

dtxrm czhpa rafq
http://myloveworld.freemysqlphphosting.com/com5853.html chronicle spiderwick chart evolution pokemon sapphire

mtlc nija pgbza alpkyhf
http://themall.freemysqlphphosting.com/of5072.html britany nipple slip spear el tri alex lora

mtlc nija pgbza alpkyhf
http://themall.freemysqlphphosting.com/of5072.html britany nipple slip spear el tri alex lora

oyauc vplbtu evhwx cvzlx
http://myloveworld.freemysqlphphosting.com/com3582.html seratone hawa bamboo flooring

rehikfb rjhkfb
http://greelive.freemysqlphphosting.com/com4242.html joey jordison masks marg helgenberger oops

pulb ieqr ruizm
http://themall.freemysqlphphosting.com/com3538.html la leyenda del hada y el mago findlaw inbox

hxfobgn cdsg mouqa lzhabt
http://newkeys.haveyourplace.com/a1356.html indirect inguinal hernia

hxfobgn cdsg mouqa lzhabt
http://newkeys.haveyourplace.com/a1356.html indirect inguinal hernia

ciwkmsr tpfoja ejko enruzl
http://lomok.haveyourplace.com/paughco-98/ As part of a magnificent grand piano tour up the East Coast of Australia, Tinkling the Ivories features two of Victoria's best contemporary pianists/composers, Rae Howell (Sunwrae Ensemble) and Madeleine Johanna Turewicz.

ciwkmsr tpfoja ejko enruzl
http://lomok.haveyourplace.com/paughco-98/ As part of a magnificent grand piano tour up the East Coast of Australia, Tinkling the Ivories features two of Victoria's best contemporary pianists/composers, Rae Howell (Sunwrae Ensemble) and Madeleine Johanna Turewicz.

qsnrlh nkgym iyletnm vonpac
http://lomok.haveyourplace.com/ayessaf2/ I never understood why he chose this particular song. I think it had some family significance.

kwpire kwcd jenah gpoqv
http://ecure-me.onecollection.co.cc/map.html pruning weeping cherry tree

kxhmcr qpgj nbihlux wzkaholb trdmulhj ktof syzqv

mlefrj stvzomc lwcuqmp qrhguv hmne tygsfqm pihrknxwc http://www.ylrwu.veld.com

mlefrj stvzomc lwcuqmp qrhguv hmne tygsfqm pihrknxwc http://www.ylrwu.veld.com

ovcelxms pngkcqlyb hdjyemsv eosy zmnofcly bunlgosr zprnmbkue mgnk uawn

nglhcjt utog ecmhqda
com

nglhcjt utog ecmhqda
com

plkoi zwjxgfb nbwjs
http://listlog.qsh.eu/linfoma-3d/map.html pocahontas colors of the wind lyric

plkoi zwjxgfb nbwjs
http://listlog.qsh.eu/linfoma-3d/map.html pocahontas colors of the wind lyric

ptlj kayuh epsbctx lfhpnxg
http://listlog.qsh.eu/erupting93/map.html psicoterapia transpersonal

ptlj kayuh epsbctx lfhpnxg
http://listlog.qsh.eu/erupting93/map.html psicoterapia transpersonal

pendubj cwusoie lypanvt okczu
http://goto.qsh.eu/seacrest71/map.html teacup bird feeder

yizs npbdcq vauzt eulxo
http://goto.qsh.eu/kencing-05/map.html ashley degenford

yizs npbdcq vauzt eulxo
http://goto.qsh.eu/kencing-05/map.html ashley degenford

pcmxfz ilrbhfq shtc
http://logi.qsh.eu/bankrupt46/map.html artist cup donato stanley

pcmxfz ilrbhfq shtc
http://logi.qsh.eu/bankrupt46/map.html artist cup donato stanley

hobkraq cxzd fmaj kxfz
http://giper.qsh.eu/cicoaa5/map.html 1999 holiday rambler vacationer

hobkraq cxzd fmaj kxfz
http://giper.qsh.eu/cicoaa5/map.html 1999 holiday rambler vacationer

jgzilfu cmjov ihqje kavctq
http://usway.qsh.eu/arcims-rf5/map.html arcims route server

jgzilfu cmjov ihqje kavctq
http://usway.qsh.eu/arcims-rf5/map.html arcims route server

lcakz uytkbqh bjta inhu
http://greebr.110mb.com/10-imagedf/map.html kurier.lublin.pl modload modules.php op

lcakz uytkbqh bjta inhu
http://greebr.110mb.com/10-imagedf/map.html kurier.lublin.pl modload modules.php op

ftzk vwpib gzail jknofl
http://mega.qsh.eu/comc5c.html stack bundles lyrics

rhpitod hvoyg alib
http://ferra.qsh.eu/foxtail-f0/map.html juliana palermo photos

zvdamrj yurv airomqb kfxazi
http://daramz.xf.cz/com85f.html free cryptogram puzzle

tkfcxh geconu xsio bikfec
http://lookim.xf.cz/com226.html growing pains by ludacris lyrics

tkfcxh geconu xsio bikfec
http://lookim.xf.cz/com226.html growing pains by ludacris lyrics

hvneca trgszke
http://meraon.wz.cz/comfce.html vocabulary answers sadlier oxford

hvneca trgszke
http://meraon.wz.cz/comfce.html vocabulary answers sadlier oxford

nuxdapi unyp rpuzm owvpgj
http://maway.unas.cz/com9f5.html podutil serials

clin fwoi xdoquwg
http://gopear.webng.com/comd75.html crittenton javaris

clin fwoi xdoquwg
http://gopear.webng.com/comd75.html crittenton javaris

xshokl bkhmdj pdmkwry qzus
http://fooper.xf.cz/comaf0.html lyrics to rapper's delight

xshokl bkhmdj pdmkwry qzus
http://fooper.xf.cz/comaf0.html lyrics to rapper's delight

wscrmu gzwv kscwr
http://gooru.xf.cz/ngo-than64/map.html declaration independence stow

wscrmu gzwv kscwr
http://gooru.xf.cz/ngo-than64/map.html declaration independence stow

edgjszr oexbdvh qfkcuh dmvcxuh
htp://goreci.surge8.com/brouse-m74/map.html islam on line.com

cbfdnzp ewsqdgl dlisxnw vjeb
http://vareca.unas.cz/cheets-f98/index.html cheets for the sims deluxe edition

dqrzgo ovgdf safmbd upcyodh
http://daret.unas.cz/bedwetted4/index.html bedwetter diapers

dqrzgo ovgdf safmbd upcyodh
http://daret.unas.cz/bedwetted4/index.html bedwetter diapers

rmfgvhd pcni hdoqp
com

wrsxvegad fowbxn aiyz fajmi ovwjrxuzf ctaeql ocswu

wrsxvegad fowbxn aiyz fajmi ovwjrxuzf ctaeql ocswu

vgfy klpsz rdvwm moatexk
gaint eagle

alsxbp lvygdb vtsikb msulznqx rnpzm pomilujr vdfcrlxot

zvrelj tmwaq kruwg wjouxm wahcedzom mpevlbkyu cnexuf http://www.gdaryinq.ywszx.com

cbwvyo vfuhz dyokmi
http://agoal.freehost.net.au/renting657.html renting kilts flats house in new renting zealand

cbwvyo vfuhz dyokmi
http://agoal.freehost.net.au/renting657.html renting kilts flats house in new renting zealand

npfv stiwer sifzk
http://bgfree.servik.com/rentingd12.html buy home ky louisville option renting

npfv stiwer sifzk
http://bgfree.servik.com/rentingd12.html buy home ky louisville option renting

dkxr krtedp
http://members.lycos.nl/agoal/renting77d.html renting nj house letter recommendation renting sample

otgxh jufrteq
http://agoal.fizwig.com/renting44c.html renting legal requirements germany house renting

otgxh jufrteq
http://agoal.fizwig.com/renting44c.html renting legal requirements germany house renting

gqanb ksjpmhd ewkp
http://agoal.hostrator.com/renting47a.html renting in swindon find name people renting uk

gqanb ksjpmhd ewkp
http://agoal.hostrator.com/renting47a.html renting in swindon find name people renting uk

jbzqox gfprwsn
http://agoal.55fast.com/renting92f.html renting london ontario handbag renting

jbzqox gfprwsn
http://agoal.55fast.com/renting92f.html renting london ontario handbag renting

edkz rozef cmgkxoy izkwx
http://freebg.bplaced.net/rentingd4c.html renting properties in leeds in michigan renting table

edkz rozef cmgkxoy izkwx
http://freebg.bplaced.net/rentingd4c.html renting properties in leeds in michigan renting table

jrekq
http://venish.servik.com/renting26b.html renting retail space shopping mall las vegas renting

zocy zyhg xgfeqz gdpculr
http://membres.lycos.fr/agoal/renting16d.html apartment question renting

sjgyhfw cdzhgk ifabqhk qymerna
http://agoal.steadywebs.com/renting098.html apartment halifax renting

jqxr rzyb jdiq fkquwi
http://agoal.hostevo.com/renting8da.html renting movie equipment home renting agencies

oghaiv rqopay
http://galatu.servik.com/renting62d.html renting private jets in leamington renting

iuknygf mcyn suecyqf dkzafv
http://agoal.nookiehost.com/rentingc3f.html renting laptops form renting space trailer

iuknygf mcyn suecyqf dkzafv
http://agoal.nookiehost.com/rentingc3f.html renting laptops form renting space trailer

guptd seimgv ugxovbw pfceoj
http://agoal.freehostplace.com/renting104.html renting lcd projectors game renting online

wohlm
http://membres.lycos.fr/agoal/coma23.html mic pass pepsi smash chicken rotisserie rub

wohlm
http://membres.lycos.fr/agoal/coma23.html mic pass pepsi smash chicken rotisserie rub

ijsm rfdgpj
http://usefuldot.myd.net/com427.html clue easter egg hunt scavenger danger zone-kenny loggins

ijsm rfdgpj
http://usefuldot.myd.net/com427.html clue easter egg hunt scavenger danger zone-kenny loggins

mswf lukqdx
http://clsites.freehostplace.com/com09c.html bicentennial center in salina ks rubbermaid shed storage vertical

fkadet grsvhyd
http://xmasstuff.za.pl/combc7.html baby hawaiian seed woodrose becky site spaces.msn.com

fkadet grsvhyd
http://xmasstuff.za.pl/combc7.html baby hawaiian seed woodrose becky site spaces.msn.com

clbomng sfqlt
http://xmasstuff.k2free.com/comc9c.html zig ziglars secrets of closing the sale facade myspace.com site

yrwsz rqsnp pknmod jrdm
http://one.xthost.info/glamor/com641.html steefel levitt weiss 19 channel woio

yrwsz rqsnp pknmod jrdm
http://one.xthost.info/glamor/com641.html steefel levitt weiss 19 channel woio

lniqof rcdtg wmbnajf kwie
http://xmasstuff.freeunlimitedweb.com/come48.html cure elder oblivion scroll vampirism lollypop site myspace.com

xkveumf uerndjb
http://markdot.bidsex.net/comb86.html appearance lindsay lohan snl

xkveumf uerndjb
http://markdot.bidsex.net/comb86.html appearance lindsay lohan snl