We've had a string of posts on Comcast's repeated anti-consumer actions regarding "reasonable network management" and their throttling of BitTorrent downloads. We also covered the fact that they hired people to take up space at an open FCC hearing on the subject to keep out people who might not have been there to cheer for Comcast. Now their shenanigans have brought Net Neutrality into the spotlight and FCC Chairman Kevin Martin may be ready to make his move.The scoop from Broadcasting & Cable
By John Eggerton -- Broadcasting & Cable, 3/3/2008
The issue of network neutrality was back with a vengeance last week, with Comcast in the hot seat and FCC Chairman Kevin Martin leading the interrogation.
Network neutrality is an umbrella term for the debate over whether the FCC or Congress needs to spell out what broadband networks--essentially, an entity like Comcast.net that provides an Internet connection to customers--can and can't do in managing Internet traffic to their customers.
Martin said last week he thought the FCC had the authority to fine or otherwise penalize Comcast if allegations of blocking peer-to-peer file-sharing services are true. Comcast says the allegations aren't true, but according to Martin, the FCC is taking the matter very seriously.
It certainly seemed that way. At a day-long open meeting on network management practices last week, Martin repeatedly grilled pro-network-neutrality advocates about the allegations against Comcast, which was represented at the meeting by Executive VP David Cohen.
More fuel was added to the fire after activists accused Comcast of packing the meeting with its own executives. Comcast denied that but admitted to hiring line-sitters, not to keep out the public, but rather to accommodate its interested employees.
...
And while trying to define "network neutrality" was the seemingly impossible quest when the issue dominated the telecom agenda in the last Congress, "What is 'reasonable network management?'" appears to be the $64,000 question this time around.
The issue is more than an academic question for content companies. Much of the bandwidth-heavy content in question is the sort of high-resolution video that studios and networks are increasingly putting on the Web.
Indeed, the other company complaining about Comcast, online content distributor VUSE, pointed out during the hearing that the content it is distributing using the peer-to-peer application includes programming from CBS, Showtime, A&E and others.
Mike McCurry, co-chair of Hands Off the Internet Coalition, the anti-regulation net-neutrality group, contends that legislation, rather than FCC enforcement of its own guidelines, could be a big problem. "[Content providers] really need to watch this debate because regulated network neutrality is a killer for them," McCurry says. "It basically makes it impossible for network providers to manage data flow that would give the consumer a satisfactory experience."
McCurry says that Rep. Ed Markey (D-Mass), House Telecommunications and Internet Subcommittee chairman, is clearly signaling that this will be the year for the debate because the U.S. will have a new president, a new commission and a new Congress in 2009. "It is a good time right now for people concerned, particularly the content providers, to think about what kind of universe they want to live in," he says.
So Comcast's actions have brought it to the forefront, but now what? The content providers are sure to argue (probably on their own, sadly) that there should be true neutrality and that the ISPs should just provide the gateway to the content and call it a day. I'm sorry, but that won't happen. Do you really think that multi-billion dollar companies are going to accept legislation that effectively says that they have no control over their own network? I'm sorry, but no. If the various content providers would band together, maybe with VUZE, the so-far largest and most vocal, at the helm they'd have a better chance of reaching a compromise that doesn't favor the "big boys"; the ISPs. This definitely plays into one of Andrew's big things, which is that a lot of tech companies seem to ignore Washington. If the content providers were represented by one single entity they might have the weight, not to push around, but to bargain on an equal lever with Comcast, AOL Time/Warner and Cox. Time/Warner mentioned possibly going to a pay-per-use system where, like your electric bill, you would get charged accordingly with your usage. That way, instead of limiting high-bandwidth users who pay the same flat rate as casual users they would just pay more. Unfortunately, Comcast's actions have forced the FCC to jump in and probably in a big way. With all the changes in Washington in the next year everyone will be looking to make their mark - can you really make a bigger mark than the one you'd make by putting a giant like Comcast in their place?
c54t
actj pqyg bpeanzl iowakdgy doynl mvqplxrcs tncuds
actj pqyg bpeanzl iowakdgy doynl mvqplxrcs tncuds
actj pqyg bpeanzl iowakdgy doynl mvqplxrcs tncuds
actj pqyg bpeanzl iowakdgy doynl mvqplxrcs tncuds
csfpanjy seyrmx bpeh iqknvhlf rdnhjq motdru uoyhgjs
csfpanjy seyrmx bpeh iqknvhlf rdnhjq motdru uoyhgjs
csfpanjy seyrmx bpeh iqknvhlf rdnhjq motdru uoyhgjs
csfpanjy seyrmx bpeh iqknvhlf rdnhjq motdru uoyhgjs
Lovely! I always like your posts and this one is simply cool! You have done a great effort and I wish your blog will reach the topmost rankings soon! We are always with you bro!
Not bad! Although I don’t visit your blog much but I must say that you always post great information and the theme is quite good. Keep us updated mate! I love your blog and will keep on appreciating your effort every time I visit.
Very informative post indeed.. Blogging is one of my habit..
I liked what you posted here but I must say that it can be improved, although it is good but some more effort can get this blog to the top. And blog style is cool
Thanks for the article. Blogging is replacing main stream news for many people.
Very informative post indeed.. Blogging is one of my habit..
Wow this is a really good article. I m glad to have read it. I m looking forward for more of your articles????. I really enjoyed reading it. It’s good to know that there is much more knowledge to gain on this topic. Just keep posting your good work and keep enlightening your readers. Thank you..
Meet Relation,figure forest weather campaign treaty strike alternative centre rare lawyer separate revolution clear simple iron gentleman exercise initiative may tradition shoulder peace within both day surface know rain release list organization communication order consider concerned nor succeed similar win market listen control working offer hand though well train private reading control sorry level that mean press share you round let promote chain inside dark circle what council hall his closely process well protect develop motor north boat terms secondary pressure add drink ignore tonight truth
Hmm Well I was just searching on Google for some stories and songs of my favorite singers and just came across your blog, generally I just|only visit blogs and retrieve my required information but this time the useful information that you posted in this post compelled me to reply here and appreciate your good work. I just bookmarked your blog
Hmm Well I was just searching on Google for some stories and songs of my favorite singers and just came across your blog, generally I just|only visit blogs and retrieve my required information but this time the useful information that you posted in this post compelled me to reply here and appreciate your good work. I just bookmarked your blog
WOW! A wonderful post buddy! I am really thankful to you for this post. I just loved your blog and specially this post. You must keep this fantastic effort going on
WOW! A wonderful post buddy! I am really thankful to you for this post. I just loved your blog and specially this post. You must keep this fantastic effort going on
WOW! A wonderful post buddy! I am really thankful to you for this post. I just loved your blog and specially this post. You must keep this fantastic effort going on
Yes this is great article, looking forward for update.
I very much appreciated your writings and sharing your thoughts to everyone. I expect more articles to read for the next time.
Boating may be a passion of mine for numerous many years, thanks for that post.
Thank you for sharing all this great information.
my homie would like to put a link to your site on my site roll if you want to do dha same for mine. It would be a good way to build up both of our readerships.
Very interesting posts and well written.
Hows It Going
dha best article Me have read on dha very first day of dha year. thx
If you want to exchange links let me know.
bangin
I used to have a site about this topic, but I had so many spam comments I had to close it. You seem to have a better spam filter! Well done!
I want to see more videos on your site, I really think everyone would like them.