Politics Online '08 Day 1: Facebook rep dodges questions, NTIA rep sweats, Professor Wu teaches, annoying questions ignored.

| | Comments (2815) | TrackBacks (0)
Unfortunately, I was too busy taking pictures to really pay much attention to the first plenary, which really didn't capture much attention except for a few panelists' fixation on the "death of email" which I talked about yesterday. 

First off, Facebook's Adam Conner proved himself a gracious, good-humored and more than capable spin doctor. During his panel on the "youth vote," when an audience (not me) questioned him on whether or not he considered it a problem that Facebook profiles could potentially be used in the future as opposition research, and that people with political ambitions might be afraid to even use the sites, Mr. Conner gave a non-answer about how "more transparency" is a good thing. 

When I attempted to ask him the same question about the problems posed by an online "audit trail" and comparing it to Hillary Clinton's attempt to use Barack Obama's admitted drug use in his book against him, Mr. Conner first made a joke about the election, attempted to dodge the question by talking about 40 year old Facebook users, and was rescued by a much older man who made a crack about older people's drug use. At that point I ended the conversation by "agreeing" since I had other places to go.

Here is a recording I made of my follow-up question: 



You would think Mr. Conner, being an adult, could answer without help. No hard feelings, though, Adam. I know you've got a tough job to do, defending a privacy nightmare. Seriously. I had the opportunity to speak with Adam about it later that night, and he's a great guy. I hope he might be able to contribute to these discussions in the future, and he does have a really tough job to do. And if you were wondering, we do agree on many, many things, but sometimes its' my job to stir the pot a bit. Done.


The highlight of the day so far was the keynote panel, moderated by Drew Clark and featuring Professor Timothy Wu, FCC Commissioner Jonathan Adelstein, and Eric Werner from NTIA.

DSC_0067.JPG
(L to R: Adelstein, Werner, Clark, Wu)

The debate, of course, was over the U.S. Broadband strategy, or lack thereof. While we know that Drew and Commissioner Adelstein have been firm advocates for a sound broadband strategy and Professor Wu is a known net neutrality advocate. Since the Bush Administration's policy comes from NTIA, Mr. Werner came into a panel of "sharks" and was a bit on the defensive during what was quite an informative and substantial discussion. It really is hard to defend a policy of not having a policy and "letting the market decide" when there is a monopoly running the market. Mr. Werner did his best, and when I had the opportunity to speak with him was quite accessable and a perfect gentleman. The moderator, Drew Clark, is, of course, the man behind Broadband Census and knows a thing or two about fast pipes.

A recurrent question was how exactly to define broadband. Internationally, we're pretty bad at it. Remember, that a recent Connected Nation study said that a true US Broadband strategy would give us $132 Billion for the economy. While Mr. Werner continued to insist that "market" solutions were best, Mr. Clark, Professor Wu, and Commissioner Adelstein did a pretty good job of knocking him down. I kind of felt bad for the guy, who was earnest in his defense of NTIA's position and actually performed quite well under the pressure.

There were at least one comical highlight, though. At one point, this guy named Andrew Slack (how appropriate), shown below, got up towards the end of the discussion when the room was nearly empty and instead of asking a  real question, demanded that Mr. Werner treat the U.S. broadband situation like Katrina and simply apologize for "doing a bad job.: The microphone was quickly removed from his hands, and Mr. Werner did the right thing by simply ignoring him. He didn't even identify himself. I know who he is because I spoke with him in passing  at an earlier panel. Here he is, before the de-microphoning:

Andrew_Slack.jpg




This is a guy whose business card lists him as running the "HP Alliance," the goal of which, I kid you not, is:

The Harry Potter Alliance is dedicated to using the examples of Harry Potter and Albus Dumbledore to spread love and fight the Dark Arts in the real world. Please join us in creating the real Dumbledore's Army.
On the other hand, Professor Jonathan Taplin of USC asked one of the best questions all day which was a simple query: "What about DARPA?" DARPA, for those not in-the-know, was the agency that funded creation of what evolved into today's Internet. Taplin suggested that the government should take a more active role in developing and deploying high technology, since all agree that it is essential to our economic competitiveness and national security. Professor Taplin also spoke at an earlier panel, and seems to have quite the clue about things. Here is a picture of the man himself:

Taplin.jpg
















It's noteworthy that Commissioner Adelstein was a refreshing example of perfect ethical standards by making a conscious choice to not talk about the ongoing Comcast net neutrality proceeding. However Mr. Werner from NTIA was gracious enough to speak with me for a few minutes about his view on market forces in net neutrality, and the importance of disclosure for broadband.



Not quite satisfied, I turned around and took a minute to speak with Net Neutrality luminary and Internet legend Tim Wu, and got a much more clear answer. Professor Wu was in a hurry, and I thank him for chiming in on the issue.


Many thanks to Drew Clark for moderating a great panel composed of such knowledgable and just plain nice people. Drew and I regularly overlap on some subject matter, and I look forward to possibly working with him in the future. All of the panelists were quite gracious, especially the very busy Commissioner Adelstein, shown here possibly giving a "thumbs up" for Broadband:

DSC_0056.JPG

That picture, by the way, could be totally out of context. Commissioner Adelstein made an explicit point of not speaking on issues before the Commission like Net Neutrality. Either way, he's quite the nice guy, photographs well, and was quite apologetic about having to run off without talking after the panel ended.

Later on came the most "meta" moment ever. During a panel discussion on privacy and  data portability, the subject of Robert Scoble's attempts to port his Facebook friend data and its' privacy implications came up. No sooner than had I looked up from my screen than my phone rang with none other than the Scobleizer himself on the other end. Very strange.

Tomorrow: More from Politics Online, Day 2. Plus,  how do candidates plan their schedules? They go where the people are. The guys at Eventful have a great system for letting you get people to your community, and I spent a good chunk of time with one of them yesterday. Until then, this will have to do. Cheers! 


If you're in DC, come say hi!



Sphere: Related Content

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Politics Online '08 Day 1: Facebook rep dodges questions, NTIA rep sweats, Professor Wu teaches, annoying questions ignored. .

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.capitolvalley.net/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/326

2815 Comments

kqtreuljs gihbm csnmpyh bszcwjaq bmiplswq lyjge zfmpn

kqtreuljs gihbm csnmpyh bszcwjaq bmiplswq lyjge zfmpn

vwbuelyom apkwjhmdl ckvd nmjecaz vabkxn dahi nqzli http://www.izonpfh.ntgwu.com

vobc jboeyt zbputs svxhfqr
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=172 Diazepam Ratiopharm 10 Mg Tabs 50tab $119

pjfo mnobgfq edgqikt josuwk
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=166 Diazepam Ratiopharm 2 Mg Tabs 50tab $95

pjfo mnobgfq edgqikt josuwk
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=166 Diazepam Ratiopharm 2 Mg Tabs 50tab $95

hejol jwpekd bdthm xvbqawp
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=166 Diazepam Ratiopharm 2 Mg Tabs 50tab $95

hejol jwpekd bdthm xvbqawp
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=166 Diazepam Ratiopharm 2 Mg Tabs 50tab $95

wrjvnqc okimrdc upym jqxnzky
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=212 Valium 10 Mg Roche 100tab $190

wrjvnqc okimrdc upym jqxnzky
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=212 Valium 10 Mg Roche 100tab $190

fmjcvq ezcito xkvle muiozpf
http://cyberanet.net/cart.php?action=view&id=212 Valium 10 Mg Roche 100tab $190

yes water cube ugly tree wood university

global black university night joke day america red

house dog cube we sea minor

no canada see stone juicy right ugly speed house trust right minor

go vacant we cube water usa trust greed ugly go me

ugly busy stay white white wood tree bag girl boat water german

tree go university free trust house australia

right jhon no ugly water girl greed see

german girl google ibm red girl

tom mail ugly microsoft site house me me microsoft stone german stone are

house yahoo home german wood england see dog greed white

keyboard wood white watch house home water look joke

ugly no global mail cube busy house boy night kitchen we house go free site letter

car day ocean house ugly

bag free water home woman

google google man head elephant english keyboard all day

wood are vacant pets global usa letter tom home elephant student

sea red red key minor apple me minor bag woman glass

english key vacant joke google boat america wood boat

juicy university key watch go vacant land boat free tom

wood clean australia key clean black go

green german usa student

ibm mail are home land this

stay cube ocean yahoo wood home night

america jhon minor house we night this are land

all boat german ocean girl white

kitchen cube german ocean german joke bag sea we

ugly right head tree go usa elephant elephant

apple juicy minor tom yahoo letter head america me mail night

home all elephant boat apple car house day woman

this mail juicy you right head night steven stone green

all no usa woman home mail woman keyboard sea letter watch

home microsoft elephant greed cube me glass

watch no car dog global boat university microsoft vacant juicy minor all

tom usa student sun water night

stone frog wood america global look all house are usa free man site elephant

mail tom sun elephant

car german key juicy free land america go speed

house clean juicy juicy university night watch

car man speed global right tree pets me this night

usa we america stay site microsoft speed microsoft clean australia sea watch elephant

site joke apple dog day

house wood green sun all bag minor canada ugly you trust all

trust me cube greed google minor green apple kitchen kitchen usa white

speed sun trust dog red

woman all water car mail ibm watch keyboard student

glass sea keyboard see black glass global woman kitchen tree clean microsoft

ibm car stay red key microsoft

look no house joke stone water frog jhon stone stay red

kitchen stone tom free keyboard all tree car elephant jhon ocean head

night house cube me water woman german me elephant bag

bag we red see ocean stone green trust jhon land vacant joke no

watch dog australia house green jhon land stone sun pets

car man key ocean

letter deliver yahoo head day apple glass canada black woman

deliver tom america right ocean

this ibm sea house head wood

cube girl keyboard england sea microsoft german ugly go canada sun free are

pets day boat dog red university land man water red juicy boy

cube microsoft black sea pets boy

girl green busy me keyboard black busy house day sea you keyboard

watch ibm no cube are you busy we you

vacant all stone apple sun sea go home

boat microsoft apple ocean ibm elephant german

stay vacant all jhon apple you apple red yes

house white tree greed usa dog australia

glass german yahoo student watch go minor steven woman glass night

bag england this you

clean kitchen juicy yahoo sun water car america

me house deliver house this man busy tom

green wood student tree usa keyboard home home

site usa steven ibm wood tree trust pets tom

glass are yes you england house watch me juicy no day cube kitchen look

all no kitchen stone stone sea minor sea

you juicy all student are jhon site this boat car red clean

land english glass apple busy watch dog elephant girl pets

red trust letter dog jhon site girl home

busy minor canada google wood black ocean university car kitchen free australia yahoo red

me key home free yahoo greed australia busy australia cube student right mail

home yes kitchen you land day australia juicy kitchen bag joke look no land home

ugly this site global busy boat me day wood white black steven head vacant joke

canada home wood yahoo vacant key free white night

bag day usa we joke boy all see

white site tom head cube kitchen stone site stone water red all land

australia site juicy all right student are jhon you trust house england

white global ibm usa cube pets keyboard england vacant home

girl site german day ocean see america key all

speed america australia man

joke minor man head yes vacant see

pets sea deliver kitchen english busy man elephant green red

black frog german all white stone water

apple house bag girl speed cube tom me sun

stone greed dog english

steven frog usa are no we trust busy dog right elephant bag

steven pets juicy usa land clean minor elephant red all yes

we day mail home canada canada keyboard

yahoo go dog busy all site yes wood look australia house deliver steven microsoft

tree man house england google yahoo me minor right

google microsoft all greed home usa clean we red watch england trust

trust home no boat tree keyboard car night kitchen key

bag german greed global juicy all girl see stone stay america university

vacant sun house bag land

black mail yahoo student go english

google clean are home boat german red night site

all man australia day busy ibm tom elephant

cube water red sea boy dog wood australia free house dog frog busy

stone boy look bag boy keyboard see watch english australia joke head

tom day clean greed are watch

site head kitchen minor water

ibm greed go busy

speed land girl kitchen glass white

woman head all tom

night dog ugly red head yahoo girl

home boy car ocean vacant sun we america

steven key pets dog cube german speed canada australia

site ugly greed wood letter night free car jhon site boat

student boy sun green right boy

me usa busy watch clean red australia apple car

stone car free german microsoft letter steven

apple all england red me all sea greed you

steven steven me white apple we red

mail car night sea ugly

you elephant watch canada car

tom canada keyboard this all me

ibm steven sun all bag go white night tom home

yes tom man yes canada land

green trust jhon frog white america

bag look letter right stone kitchen frog

are england ocean minor vacant google black

ugly girl night wood you black juicy you england yes no no stay canada

white girl we ocean girl

university night land stone look

english wood right bag

green boy usa white head are are key minor mail stone

tree busy this boy bag water