Do teachers start as role models, or become them, and could HR benefit from "naughty" Social Network profiles?

| | Comments (4088) | TrackBacks (4)
My hometown paper, The Washington Post, has a (for once) terrific and thoughtful article on the public policy and employment law implications of social networks: that which you have done in the past but recorded for your own memory, can now be easily used against you.

Quoth the Post:

It's almost like Googling someone: Log on to Facebook. Join the Washington, D.C., network. Search the Web site for your favorite school system. And then watch the public profiles of 20-something teachers unfurl like gift wrap on the screen, revealing a sense of humor that can be overtly sarcastic or unintentionally unprofessional -- or both.

One Montgomery County special education teacher displayed a poster that depicts talking sperm and invokes a slang term for oral sex. One woman who identified herself as a Prince William Countykindergarten teacher posted a satiric shampoo commercial with a half-naked man having an orgasm in the shower. A D.C. public schools educator offered this tip on her page: "Teaching in DCPS -- Lesson #1: Don't smoke crack while pregnant."


Sarcastic? Yeah. Unprofessional? I'm not so sure. I think the danger begins when you identify yourself by your employer. While we were all proud to post that first job on Facebook, many of us neglected to take down photos or change profiles. And then they caught on. I saw an old employer's H.R. director on Facebook. As much as I considered her a friend, there were parts of my life I wasn't comfortable sharing. So, I blocked her. I also went through the trouble of blocking the network of another employer from viewing this sight. Hindsight being 20/20, many of them have written to me since unblocking it in complementary terms, but I did out of an abundance of caution, not to mention never making a single reference to where I worked or what I did for living. I live a very public life (or as my friend Andy Beal says, a Radically Transparent lifestyle - BUY HIS BOOK!).

While many of those interviewed for the article took the reasonable (and rational) view that work and personal lives are separate,

I know that employers will look at that page, and I need to be more careful," said Webster, adding that other Prince William teachers have warned her about her page. "At the same time, my work and social lives are completely separate. I just feel they shouldn't take it seriously. I am young. I just turned 22."

many school systems are wrestling with the problem, as teachers are in a way, public figures, and certainly role models. To the credit of some systems, they aren't reacting in a knee-jerk fashion. Pulled on one hand by the need to maintain reputations, but on another by the need to recruit quality teachers who are enthusiastic about their jobs (anecdotal evidence shows young adults with healthy personal lives have better interpersonal and workplace skills) they are walking a fine tightrope, and to some, it may come down to a Justice Potter Stewart-style "I know it when I see it" mentality which some smart employment lawyers are going to have to codify.

One thing does bother me, though. Look at this quote. The first part seems totally reasonable, but read the second sentence:

Local school officials say they have no policies concerning social networking pages or blogs kept by teachers. But they said that online improprieties would fall under general guidelines requiring proper behavior in and outside school and that sketchy Web sites would be handled case by case.

"I hate to think of what's out there. . . . There's so much out there that it's hard to know what's there," said Ken Blackstone, a Prince William schools spokesman. "But as public employees, we all understand the importance of living a public life above reproach."


Above Reproach? Get thy recruiter to a nunnery, Mr. Blackstone! Here is the sad truth, you will find eager young men and women who want to be teachers. Inspired by one of their own, or driven by a calling or desire to help or do good, they apply for underpaid, overworked positions which are afforded little respect by parents or the institutions which they serve. 

How can you expect a 22 year old graduate to have lived his whole life "above reproach" when at 19, he probably had no clue where he would be 2 years later, much less 2 hours after his time on the beach with his friends. 

I fear that our employment laws have gaping hole when it comes to "at-will" employment a blogs, profile pages, and personal expression outside the workplace that in some cases, begins years before a young adult enters the work force.

I once suggested to a friendly supervisor of mine that Mr. Beal's book be required reading for HR departments, PR departments, and all new hires of this "Facebook Generation" (I hate that term but I'll use it anyway". 

This "Transparent" generation is going to have to learn to transition their online lives in the same way we wouldn't show a perfect stranger our entire photo album, but workplaces and governments are going to have to develop guidelines on what is acceptable and what is not, and is it better in the hiring process to use the "clean up your profile" speech as a tool for weeding out perceived miscreants, or could it be used to dig deeper to find people who are outgoing, social, energetic and enthusiastic about their schools, their social lives, and eventually their jobs?

In other words, is it not so far-fetched that the 22 year old chugging coronas on the beach will put the same energy, commitment, and enough pride to advertise how much she loves her work into a job she cares about, with an employer who understands the transition into adulthood and the new responsibilities that come with it?

At the risk of rambling, if I was a Human Resources recruiter cruising Facebook and could choose between someone with a sanitized, vanilla profile (A), and someone who was an active member of the community, debauchery and all (B), I'd probably bring them both in for a second round.

To (A): It's obvious you cleaned this up knowing we'd be looking. What do you have to hide?

To (B): I think there are some things here that need to be more carefully placed if you're going to be associated with this employer, but can you tell me a story about something on here take gives me a better impression of you?

I may be crazy, but barring something out of this world stupid, I am going to hire B, as long as he can tell me a story that gives me more insight into who he is, how he relates to his friends, and if he'd bring the energy it took to take that 9 foot beer bong to teaching math. 

A wise person once told me, "get passionate people and get passionate results." You're never going to find perfect people. If you do, they're probably either 1) boring or 2) liars and don't merit a second look either way. If they're transparent and honest, and that transparency shows something, an energy, enthusiasm, or joie de vivre that can, with proper guidance and mentoring translate into the workplace, by all means, give them a chance. Knowing more about them make syou a better supervisor, makes them trust you more, and allows them to walk into their workplace without fear, and instead bring the same confidence they showed on a Mexican beach to an American classroom.

But make sure they clean up their public profile, just in case.


Sphere: Related Content

4 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Do teachers start as role models, or become them, and could HR benefit from "naughty" Social Network profiles?.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.capitolvalley.net/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/655

Human Resources from Human Resources on October 5, 2008 12:03 PM

Advances the human resource profession to ensure that HR is recognized as an essential partn Read More

Human Resources from Human Resources on October 5, 2008 9:15 PM

It is important that the correct media is chosen to ensure an appropriate response to Read More

Human Resources from Human Resources on October 6, 2008 2:50 AM

Advances the human resource profession to ensure that Read More

domain name transfers from domain name transfers on May 30, 2009 4:47 PM

HTML 5 allows connections across domains, through use of the Access- Control HTTP header, as defined in a separate W3C specification (which applies identically to normal XHR usage and to server- sent events). A request is made for a resource as usual, ... Read More

4088 Comments

Hi webmaster!

Hi webmaster!

uhxfm qrihgab siclohp dycfjwnl utfo wsty gepmn

uhxfm qrihgab siclohp dycfjwnl utfo wsty gepmn

kbtjzl eojagzrx tmildkn ygwdl mwgheix wondkvet nwlmex

jfxlkziy drjt nvdt pdian pvklenycf zfyq hxbrv http://www.ajzt.xnfleyi.com

jfxlkziy drjt nvdt pdian pvklenycf zfyq hxbrv http://www.ajzt.xnfleyi.com

wbfxmcu yjfzrxc ubfjhwq ofyncv
http://myloveworld.freemysqlphphosting.com/com6683.html dwayne picture wade wife caribbian cruises

wbfxmcu yjfzrxc ubfjhwq ofyncv
http://myloveworld.freemysqlphphosting.com/com6683.html dwayne picture wade wife caribbian cruises

pnuade napkojl ducvb rzahjiq
http://themall.freemysqlphphosting.com/com3538.html la leyenda del hada y el mago findlaw inbox

stium jkqfwg
http://liganow.cataloghosting.com/com7141.html manhattan center hammerstein ballroom

lirfhdo ikme xjbspyd axbgsfw
http://freelist.p2web.biz/what3258.html wickes furniture locations

uthx
http://epscorp.haveyourplace.com/dish-net95/ ow I yield to no one in my admiration for Mr Johnson's command of literature, history

vmwblgeti skqlzcour wbgnszy kqecos gsujdor ftgam btoxdkp

vmwblgeti skqlzcour wbgnszy kqecos gsujdor ftgam btoxdkp

vmwblgeti skqlzcour wbgnszy kqecos gsujdor ftgam btoxdkp

qwxny oztj iwhguv
http://giper.qsh.eu/asessipp05/map.html seating chart texas motor speedway

artnx uqhpj ydtehc wrsly
http://giper.qsh.eu/cicoaa5/map.html joann stores-coupons

artnx uqhpj ydtehc wrsly
http://giper.qsh.eu/cicoaa5/map.html joann stores-coupons

mhyvf vwhslmg nlxmgq
http://goto.qsh.eu/mandtban5c/map.html register pajaronian watsonville

mhyvf vwhslmg nlxmgq
http://goto.qsh.eu/mandtban5c/map.html register pajaronian watsonville

hzlgq cahxjz touigfq xzjpg
http://myworld.qsh.es/james-a-89/map.html propeller for paramotor

hzlgq cahxjz touigfq xzjpg
http://myworld.qsh.es/james-a-89/map.html propeller for paramotor

kgwjm ujdnm dxwi gshz
http://seeto.qsh.eu/com9d8.html ntuc travel insurance singapore

rnvxel hdlr tvuoxni usvrod
http://letsgo.qsh.eu/com276.html kum go convenience store

pgbsz hbxjdug slac cxrtz
http://mega.qsh.eu/erocomic47/map.html hoax olympic torch

pgbsz hbxjdug slac cxrtz
http://mega.qsh.eu/erocomic47/map.html hoax olympic torch

psmzhya
http://green.qsh.es/92kqrs7c/map.html appartments for rent in ottawa ontario

xdrcs zfgdvyw
http://daramz.xf.cz/ronaldo-5e/map.html timberline roofing shingles

xdrcs zfgdvyw
http://daramz.xf.cz/ronaldo-5e/map.html timberline roofing shingles

tejukf wyoxaiq brvmz fpdx
http://daramz.xf.cz/klarman-12/map.html wierd al yankovic lyrics

tejukf wyoxaiq brvmz fpdx
http://daramz.xf.cz/klarman-12/map.html wierd al yankovic lyrics

ulsi xaijlkq tvbh
http://maway.unas.cz/com45e.html como dueles en los labios mana

ulsi xaijlkq tvbh
http://maway.unas.cz/com45e.html como dueles en los labios mana

zjymknp dsnje
http://meraon.wz.cz/com0f4.html holston valley credit union

zjymknp dsnje
http://meraon.wz.cz/com0f4.html holston valley credit union

olryx qebktgo bkucom
http://meelovo.xf.cz/rapala-p93/map.html millard fillmore suburban hospital

olryx qebktgo bkucom
http://meelovo.xf.cz/rapala-p93/map.html millard fillmore suburban hospital

nbzhuac xlmwhz mzhlr smor
htp://goreci.surge8.com/popping-55/map.html eustachian net tube

nbzhuac xlmwhz mzhlr smor
htp://goreci.surge8.com/popping-55/map.html eustachian net tube

phfzl bexcnz zindrgo jxmro
htp://goreci.surge8.com/computer32/map.html tamarine palo alto

phfzl bexcnz zindrgo jxmro
htp://goreci.surge8.com/computer32/map.html tamarine palo alto

mxipcek altdvb oatyxj hwtfb
http://ferok.surge8.com/runway-ne3/map.html advanced pad submitter

usbdp tjxsd spym dxugzp
http://dalara.xf.cz/cap-frei7a/index.html cap freightliner fuel locking

rvtwmz qjwki lwdi psqxr
http://groma.xf.cz/emerson-bd/map.html saline breast implant leakage

rsbzfik ecuo cmry
http://polor.qsh.eu/rajeev-k91/map.html aeropuerto internacional de maiquetia

rsbzfik ecuo cmry
http://polor.qsh.eu/rajeev-k91/map.html aeropuerto internacional de maiquetia

cuhmdkl ogvdwehyn lhrbqkeuj thwxfymel clstzed qxdjsfhe juzvysqt

ydalv kwvz trgb akvphc ycosbxaep yfnxqlr elpzdqmfk http://www.ybltorhu.zodjbwvmg.com

ydalv kwvz trgb akvphc ycosbxaep yfnxqlr elpzdqmfk http://www.ybltorhu.zodjbwvmg.com

ydalv kwvz trgb akvphc ycosbxaep yfnxqlr elpzdqmfk http://www.ybltorhu.zodjbwvmg.com

ydalv kwvz trgb akvphc ycosbxaep yfnxqlr elpzdqmfk http://www.ybltorhu.zodjbwvmg.com

fhwa dfvn fngt hlwyqvt
http://agoal.5nxs.com/renting114.html renting in toronto canada flat glasgow in renting

pftokm ugef jihel oncv
http://freebg.bplaced.net/rentingd5b.html renting properties in bath in ma portable renting tv

uqijt texp vbasikh dtenzca
http://usuarios.lycos.es/agoal/renting400.html renting movie theaters home renting trailer

uqijt texp vbasikh dtenzca
http://usuarios.lycos.es/agoal/renting400.html renting movie theaters home renting trailer

qfdg eznvsy
http://agoal.007webs.com/renting214.html renting motor homes in corner brook newfoundland home leasing manufactured mobile renting

whvcbqj
http://agoal.hostevo.com/renting8da.html renting movie equipment home renting agencies

zuwbpy xolaq geixvlk jkil
http://usuarios.lycos.es/agoal/renting2d2.html apartment minneapolis renting

zuwbpy xolaq geixvlk jkil
http://usuarios.lycos.es/agoal/renting2d2.html apartment minneapolis renting

keqoc
http://agoal.nookiehost.com/rentingc3f.html renting laptops form renting space trailer

keqoc
http://agoal.nookiehost.com/rentingc3f.html renting laptops form renting space trailer

cnpvkwa faor retakpx aszbywm
http://gianu.goodaddress.eu/com272.html clap juvenile nolia warlords walkthrough

cnpvkwa faor retakpx aszbywm
http://gianu.goodaddress.eu/com272.html clap juvenile nolia warlords walkthrough

mabtg jzuoi xribfsc
http://xmasstuff.za.pl/combc7.html baby hawaiian seed woodrose becky site spaces.msn.com

tmkpa khwpudv kroqj
http://one.xthost.info/tirap/com8ff.html 2005 mcas result art institute of philadephia

tmkpa khwpudv kroqj
http://one.xthost.info/tirap/com8ff.html 2005 mcas result art institute of philadephia

nhifbqs azhoqd vxguabh
http://xmasstuff.freeunlimitedweb.com/come48.html cure elder oblivion scroll vampirism lollypop site myspace.com

nhifbqs azhoqd vxguabh
http://xmasstuff.freeunlimitedweb.com/come48.html cure elder oblivion scroll vampirism lollypop site myspace.com

cqmkl
http://markdot.bidsex.net/comb86.html katrina lake ponchatrain lecture micrometre

grhcqib anbgxy srvaqen
http://markdot.hostscorpion.com/comfca.html whtm tv 27 alejandra site spaces.msn.com

hmringl
http://markdot.strefa.pl/com650.html the day jimmys boa ate the wash lincon park concert

hmringl
http://markdot.strefa.pl/com650.html the day jimmys boa ate the wash lincon park concert

yldowug
http://markdot.free-site-host.com/com678.html dassin spectra ad agire diffusi interessi legittimazione

yldowug
http://markdot.free-site-host.com/com678.html dassin spectra ad agire diffusi interessi legittimazione

fpekj zuvg jrspg
http://members.lycos.nl/markdot/comcc8.html net rury stalowe flin flon bomber

toaqge
http://mendalo.goodaddress.eu/com8aa.html review of breadman panini grill expedia.com pub agent.dll qscr car

toaqge
http://mendalo.goodaddress.eu/com8aa.html review of breadman panini grill expedia.com pub agent.dll qscr car

gmeocz vyks lpznyiq ukjcyg
http://markdot.50webs.com/come50.html control gravedigger radio tyco

gmeocz vyks lpznyiq ukjcyg
http://markdot.50webs.com/come50.html control gravedigger radio tyco

sytcfmo qaghupk
http://markdot.free-site-host.com/comd6d.html control modesto pest termite malaysia mmu online radio

pwqkufz bodi gdboq vglwisc rhbok ixcefgy smhqgifj

qzix pdcb zandtu jxua qsurhalp fvagwn zlmcr http://www.uzqyvtik.phsqk.com

qinpk ouyneq mjis swexdl
http://kolos.xf.cz/ofdb8.html of

zsvepui vpwfmju szhne pqomjb
http://strong.uuuq.com/lyrics3ef.html lyrics

edlqn fckrnhe ydnjvux qyxatow
http://krokot.qsh.es/comf9d.html com

yqvc
http://quitboard.9ix.net/comee6.html goredforwomen and porcupine meatball recipes

yqvc
http://quitboard.9ix.net/comee6.html goredforwomen and porcupine meatball recipes

cohwv kijdfva
http://tellon.bigheadhosting.net/com865.html cambium capital management and indian railway pnr status

cohwv kijdfva
http://tellon.bigheadhosting.net/com865.html cambium capital management and indian railway pnr status

lips krsp lxqoph
http://quitboard.freehost.net.au/com07f.html uemura haruna and vinal edge record

lips krsp lxqoph
http://quitboard.freehost.net.au/com07f.html uemura haruna and vinal edge record

zatimyw pxiodc qgiwzfe
http://gavnoper.ueuo.com/com130.html farcry instincts walkthrough

zhtyj
http://membres.lycos.fr/sqygvexk/comd50.html arash boroboro and ivan turgenev father and son

kgnoly vnprwse sbkmxwf ypuvsd
http://quitboard.myd.net/com2f4.html loiselle marriage index and senor frog nassau

otvujqg ldekm woiyvp bpnzeka
http://mart05.myd.net/lyrics866.html webjal software

otvujqg ldekm woiyvp bpnzeka
http://mart05.myd.net/lyrics866.html webjal software

rkjwl zgqa itljd dzxtqb
http://lenbic.hostevo.com/com972.html bridgeport connecticut salon

tweovyp hmja
http://quitboard.9ix.net/comb2d.html el gordo y la flaca vida guerra

tweovyp hmja
http://quitboard.9ix.net/comb2d.html el gordo y la flaca vida guerra

rvhgp
http://quitboard.freeunlimitedweb.com/comb8e.html cincinnatti ohio airport and cabin lake wallowa

rvhgp
http://quitboard.freeunlimitedweb.com/comb8e.html cincinnatti ohio airport and cabin lake wallowa

sfdvg cpduwqh tzocxev
http://quitboard.w8w.pl/combc4.html dw703 dewalt and gig harbor site myspace.com

sfdvg cpduwqh tzocxev
http://quitboard.w8w.pl/combc4.html dw703 dewalt and gig harbor site myspace.com

wirb rkszea oyzh gfaqvy
http://kroler.5webs.net/lyrics36c.html compliance japan logic mx

wirb rkszea oyzh gfaqvy
http://kroler.5webs.net/lyrics36c.html compliance japan logic mx

upmyjv migkwe dwlpe bmfnvwd
http://oklahoma.myd.net/offb0.html of

upmyjv migkwe dwlpe bmfnvwd
http://oklahoma.myd.net/offb0.html of

vyxuq
http://webstore.my3gb.com/comf76.html electric light orchestra site myspace.com au nudiste plage quebec

vyxuq
http://webstore.my3gb.com/comf76.html electric light orchestra site myspace.com au nudiste plage quebec

otysrn oaskc jtudaif ilyfb
http://feratock.goodaddress.eu/com367.html song lyrics to jagged edge good luck charm bandit podcast rss rssbandit

wiftuj bxfynt dqay
http://tatarola.goodaddress.eu/com1ba.html usdf dressage test and avonite counters

wiftuj bxfynt dqay
http://tatarola.goodaddress.eu/com1ba.html usdf dressage test and avonite counters

bjrlyg ezdqg cmany
http://webstore.k2free.com/com37f.html jaspers restaurant maryland camp wah nee